At 11 a.m. on Saturday, Nov. 14, people will start gathering at Iron City Boulders on 51st Street with coffee from Lovebirds. They'll be waiting for a noon walk to visit some of the neighborhood's cats. Seven weeks later, on Wednesday, Dec. 30, Lawrence Hall at 4609 Butler Street opens to the public for the last time, from 11 a.m. to 10 p.m.
Nearly everything on Lawrenceville's calendar between those two dates follows the same pattern. You walk from one small business to the next, a few blocks at a time, and you collect a treat or a cookie at each stop. The season belongs to the corridor's storefronts. The one big room on Butler that was built to hold the whole neighborhood at once is closing in the middle of it.
November 14: a cat walk from 51st Street down Butler
The Lawrenceville Cat Crawl is new this year. Lawrenceville Together calls it the first one ever. The meetup runs from 11 a.m. to noon at Iron City Boulders, 143 51st Street. You can meet the people behind Conquer the Colony, look over items from the Pittsburgh Paw Project and get a coffee from Lovebirds before the group heads out on a winding route through the neighborhood. The organizer's announcement says the route visits 15 or more homes.
No registration is required. The organizers ask for a $5 donation to Conquer the Colony, which describes itself as a volunteer-run Pittsburgh cat rescue, funded by donations, that focuses on spay and neuter and fosters cats for adoption. Weruva helps sponsor the event.
The event page says the official map will be shared closer to the day. The business stops are already named, though, and their addresses show how much of Butler the walk covers. Here they are from the top of the street down:
- Lawrenceville Pet Supply, 5152 Butler St., for treats and supplies
- Ivy's Ice Cream Pawlor, 4126 Butler St.
- Kinship Gift, 3441 Butler St., for cat-themed products
- Black Cat Tattoos, 3439 Butler St., which is offering a special cat flash tattoo after the tour, by appointment
From 5152 down to 3439 is roughly seventeen blocks of Butler Street, covered in a three-hour window that ends at 2 p.m. Kinship Gift and Black Cat Tattoos sit two doors apart at the bottom. Pet Supply anchors the top, a few blocks from the climbing gym where the day begins.
The 4100 block, where the crawl passes a new Turkish kitchen
Ivy's Ice Cream Pawlor at 4126 Butler is two doors from the corridor's newest restaurant. This fall Halime Deniz moved Deniz Mediterranean Cuisine from McKnight Road to 4130 Butler and renamed it Agora Mediterranean Cuisine. NEXTpittsburgh reported that she had driven past the space for nearly seven years and pictured it as her own. "It was my dream place. I can't believe it is mine now," she told the outlet.
Agora is her third restaurant, and it's a family operation, with her sisters and a nephew cooking. The Agora mixed grill for two brings beef shish, lamb Adana, chicken Adana, chicken shish and lamb köfte with rice, salad and bread. The menu also has stews baked under a dough seal, Turkish mantı topped with garlic yogurt, and pide filled with spinach and mozzarella.
The part that fits a Saturday crawl is breakfast. It's served Friday through Sunday from 9 a.m. to 2 p.m., with menemen, fried eggs, cheeses, olives, honey, butter, pastries and pots of tea. NEXTpittsburgh reports that Deniz hopes to add weekday breakfast once she hires more staff. On Nov. 14, a 9 a.m. breakfast at 4130 Butler still leaves time to walk up to 51st Street before the 11 a.m. meetup.
Penn Avenue's newest bar makes what it pours
The other fall opening is a block off Butler. Second Story Spirits at 3354 Penn Ave. opened in September and builds its cocktails around its own coconut and chocolate liqueurs. According to NEXTpittsburgh's October guide, the menu includes the Pandan Express with vodka and tamarind, a chocolate, tequila and mezcal cocktail, and a frozen espresso martini made with Delanie's cold brew. Spiked sodas and nonalcoholic drinks are also on offer.
Second Story fits the season's pattern: a small producer in its own space, a short walk from the lower end of the crawl route at Kinship Gift and Black Cat Tattoos.
Lawrence Hall's last public day is Dec. 30
The exception on the corridor is Lawrence Hall, the food hall and bar at 4609 Butler. Its grand opening was April 12, 2024, according to Pittsburgh Magazine's opening-week coverage. In October the owners announced they would close at the end of 2026. WPXI reported the closure on Oct. 13.
The owners' own closing notice says they had worked toward the project since 2018, and it says what they built it for. "We have worked hard to make Lawrence Hall a place where neighbors could gather, eat well, and enjoy themselves," the notice reads. It cites rising costs, a difficult economic backdrop, and "a series of challenges and setbacks that, in aggregate, became more than we could carry."
They picked the end-of-year date so the staff could work through the holidays and so they could keep a New Year's Eve wedding that had already been booked. That wedding is why the last public day is Wednesday, Dec. 30, not the 31st. The Hall's events calendar lists Dec. 31 as closed to the public.
Until then, the Hall is open regular hours and is still booking events through December. Its vendor page lists Cuddy's Soul Food, La Palapa, Kazoku and Scoops & Cones, and Dear James is the bar. The calendar entry for Dec. 30 is called "Closing Time" and invites guests to "come in and celebrate with us, one final time." The notice names no successor for 4609 Butler. The owners write only that they hope "the spirit of this place continues on in whatever comes next."
"You showed up through a difficult opening, holidays, slow Tuesdays and packed Saturdays, and you made Lawrence Hall what it was." From Lawrence Hall's closing notice, addressed to its staff
For anyone who has hosted a group dinner or a birthday on Butler, the practical point is the booking window. Any December gathering planned for 4609 Butler has to land on or before Dec. 30.
December 12 puts two cookie walks on the same afternoon
December brings back the walk-between-stops format, this time with cookies and lights.
On Saturday, Dec. 5, Allegheny Cemetery holds its Holiday Memorial Tree Decorating from 11 a.m. to 1 p.m. at the Temple of Memories. Visitors can add an ornament, and there are cookies and cocoa.
A week later comes the season's busiest day. The 30th annual Lawrenceville Cookie Tour runs from noon to 5 p.m. on Dec. 12, with free cookies at participating small businesses. Organizers say more details are coming, so the list of participating shops hasn't been posted yet. The tour wraps up as Allegheny Cemetery holds its Cookie Walk tree lighting from 5 to 6 p.m. with Santa. After that, the tree stays lit every night for the rest of the holiday season.
Lolev's monthly bingo covers both months. It's at 5247 Butler St. from 7 to 8 p.m. on Nov. 9 and again on Dec. 14, and $10 buys four rounds, with gift cards or cash as prizes.
The full calendar, Nov. 9 through Dec. 30
| Date | Event | Where | Time |
|---|---|---|---|
| Mon., Nov. 9 | Monthly Bingo | Lolev, 5247 Butler St. | 7–8 p.m. |
| Sat., Nov. 14 | First Lawrenceville Cat Crawl | Starts at Iron City Boulders, 143 51st St. | 11 a.m.–2 p.m. |
| Sat., Dec. 5 | Holiday Memorial Tree Decorating | Allegheny Cemetery, Temple of Memories | 11 a.m.–1 p.m. |
| Sat., Dec. 12 | 30th Lawrenceville Cookie Tour | Participating small businesses | Noon–5 p.m. |
| Sat., Dec. 12 | Cookie Walk tree lighting with Santa | Allegheny Cemetery | 5–6 p.m. |
| Mon., Dec. 14 | Monthly Bingo | Lolev, 5247 Butler St. | 7–8 p.m. |
| Wed., Dec. 30 | Closing Time, last public day | Lawrence Hall, 4609 Butler St. | 11 a.m.–10 p.m. |
Weekend breakfast at Agora, 4130 Butler, runs every Friday through Sunday from 9 a.m. to 2 p.m. through the season. Second Story Spirits at 3354 Penn Ave. is the newest bar on the list.
If losing a Butler Street anchor like Lawrence Hall has you wondering what corridor changes mean for the value of your own block, Brian Teyssier follows Lawrenceville address by address. Schedule a consultation or request a free home valuation, and we'll show you how your street is pricing heading into 2027.