When Ron Booth bought 918 S. Aiken Ave. in 2002, he lived in the third-floor apartment while he restored the two floors below it. The apartment has its own outside entrance, cathedral windows and skylights. His husband, Christopher Hahn, told the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette that it looks out over the tree canopy. The house went on the market in April at $1.8 million. It is still set up as a main residence on two floors with a two-bedroom apartment above, and the Post-Gazette notes that it can be converted back into a single-family home.
That layout is common in Shadyside. Many of the neighborhood's large houses from before World War I no longer sell as plain single-family homes. They come with an apartment upstairs, they hold three households, or they have been divided into condos. Within one group of houses built in the same era, the asking price per square foot falls steeply as the number of households in the building rises. In Shadyside the cheapest square foot of old-house space is usually in a building where you also live with tenants or co-owners.
Four listings from the same era, priced four ways
The Post-Gazette's "Buying Here" column has featured four Shadyside properties between October 2025 and November 2026 that make the pattern easy to see. All four date from the 1890s to 1913. All prices below are asking prices from the date each feature ran, not sale prices.
| Address | Built | How it's set up | Size | Asking price | Approx. per sq ft |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 704 Amberson Ave. | 1913 | Single-family, seven bedrooms | 6,335 sq ft | $3.8M, Sept. 2026 | $600 |
| 918 S. Aiken Ave. | 1910 | Owner residence plus third-floor two-bedroom apartment | 3,537 sq ft | $1.8M, April 2026 | $509 |
| 6109 Fifth Ave., Apt. 2 | 1893 | One of four condos in a divided house | 1,820 sq ft | $510K, Oct. 2025 | $280 |
| 5810 Kentucky Ave. | 1890s | Three-unit apartment building, owner on top floor | 6,265 sq ft | $1.347M, Nov. 2026 | $215 |
The Amberson Avenue house and the Kentucky Avenue building are close to the same size, within about 70 square feet of each other. The Amberson house asks almost three times as much per foot. Part of the gap is the houses themselves. Amberson is a 1913 English Cottage Revival house, and its owners had a curved roof of Vermont slate rebuilt over the rounded eaves and eyebrow dormers. It was the featured house on this fall's Shadyside House Tour. Most of the gap comes from something else. A buyer at Amberson pays for 6,335 square feet that one household controls. A buyer at Kentucky gets 6,265 square feet, but the same buyer lives in only part of it.
Why the streets sort this way
Where these properties sit follows the way Shadyside was first built. A study of the neighborhood's development from 1852 to 1916, published in the October 1979 issue of Western Pennsylvania History, describes a central section between Aiken and College avenues and Ellsworth and Fifth avenues. It was laid out on lots about 25 feet wide and 100 feet deep, with detached houses only a few feet apart and no rowhouses. The study says Howe, Kentucky, Denniston and Ivy streets drew modest frame or brick houses on narrow lots, and that the apartment houses of that era were concentrated mainly between Walnut Street and Ellsworth Avenue and along Maryland Avenue.
Other streets were planned to keep apartments out. The same study describes Colonial Place, Von Lent Place and Amberson Place as early-20th-century dead-end developments of expensive small lots, and Von Lent's deed restrictions barred both apartments and stores. The stone-and-brick mansions on Morewood, Devonshire and Ellsworth formed a separate belt.
Those early decisions still show up in listings today. 5810 Kentucky was built in the 1890s as a three-unit apartment building, not as a house that was divided later. 6109 Fifth Ave. was the opposite case. It was built in 1893 on what was then called Millionaire's Row, stayed a single-family home until 1985, and was then divided into four condominiums.
Kentucky Avenue: a large building at $215 a foot
The Kentucky Avenue triplex shows the trade most clearly. The owner's residence is the 2,300-square-foot third floor, which has skylights, arched doorways and a front porch through French doors. A spiral staircase leads to a rooftop room with its own bath. The first and second floors are rented. The building has seven bedrooms and 5½ baths in total, plus a two-car tandem garage on the lower level.
The Post-Gazette reported an Allegheny County assessment of $382,000 and annual taxes of $10,065. It also reported that three single-family homes in the 5800 block of Kentucky sold between January and June 2021 for $386,250 to $785,000, according to county property records. On the same block, then, a buyer can choose between a single-family house and a 6,265-square-foot building that houses three households.
The rented floors are what put the building in that price range. As of November 1, 2026, RentCafe put Shadyside's average rent at $1,885 for a one-bedroom and $2,352 for a two-bedroom. Those averages come only from buildings with 50 or more units, so they run above what a floor in an older house typically brings. Zumper's November 2026 asking-rent figures were lower, at about $1,604 for a one-bedroom and $2,215 for a two-bedroom. RentCafe also estimates that about 71% of Shadyside households rent, based on the latest Census tenure data. In this neighborhood, a rented floor is how most residents already live.
The listing agent made a point to the Post-Gazette that matters to buyers. The building's previous owners had also lived there, and the agent said that because most apartment buildings are not owner-occupied, their care and maintenance suffer. In a building like this, part of what you pay for is the condition that decades of owners living on site left behind. The original French doors at each unit's private entrance and the brass mailbox in the foyer have survived because someone lived upstairs and looked after them.
The tax and rent figures above are dated snapshots, and this is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Confirm your own numbers with a lender, accountant or attorney before you rely on them.
Aiken Avenue: an apartment you can keep or absorb
At $509 a foot, 918 S. Aiken sits much closer to the single-family price than to the triplex. Its apartment is one floor of three, and the Post-Gazette describes it as a space the owners can keep or fold back into the house. Below the apartment, the house has four bedrooms and four full baths in total, three working fireplaces, polished black granite floors and a glass-spindled spiral staircase in the living room. Hahn told the paper the main floors can hold dinner parties of 60 to 75 guests.
Here the apartment works as an option. It can bring in rent, house a relative, or give the owners a place to live during a renovation, as Booth did. Because the owner keeps control of the whole building, the asking price per foot reads like a house price with a modest discount.
Fifth Avenue: one floor of a mansion, with co-owners
The 6109 Fifth Ave. condo sits between the two extremes, at about $280 a foot. The buyer gets 1,820 square feet with two bedrooms, 1½ baths and a one-car garage. The unit opens into what was once the house's formal dining room, which still has its coffered ceiling, judge's paneling, a leaded-glass bay window and a working fireplace. The Post-Gazette reported that the owners paid $282,500 for the unit in 2005, buying it as an investment so their son, then a nursing student at Pitt, had somewhere to live instead of renting off campus.
A condo owner here has no tenants, but shares the building with three other owners. One of the sellers served as the homeowners association's treasurer and project manager, coordinating work such as new front railings and a new floor in the common parlor. For that buyer, the old-house rooms come at about $280 a foot, alongside three neighbors who own the rest of the building. Our earlier posts on Shadyside condo HOAs and choosing between a condo and a house in Shadyside go further into that side of the decision.
What the per-foot gap means for your search
If you are comparing Shadyside with other East End neighborhoods, the neighborhood's median sale price hides this range. In the same group of 1890s-to-1913 buildings, asking prices on these four ran from about $215 to about $600 a square foot. The biggest factor was how many households share each building.
A buyer who wants old-house rooms, high ceilings and original millwork has three choices on these streets. The single-family rate, near $600 a foot at Amberson, buys sole use of every room. One floor of a divided mansion on Fifth Avenue came in at less than half that, shared with three other owners, while the whole Kentucky Avenue building asks the least per foot of any of them because two of its three floors are already rented. Carriage houses add one more variation. The $5.3 million listing at 5238 Ellsworth Ave. this January included an adjacent one-bedroom carriage house, a separate dwelling on a single-family lot. Our Shadyside carriage house guide covers that kind of property.
FAQ
Are these prices what the homes sold for? No. Every figure in this post is an asking price from the date the Post-Gazette featured the property: April 2026 for Aiken, September 2026 for Amberson, October 2025 for the Fifth Avenue condo and November 2026 for Kentucky.
Do Shadyside apartments in old houses rent for the neighborhood average? The averages published in November 2026 come from large apartment buildings and listing samples. A floor in an older house can rent above or below them depending on its layout, parking and condition.
Where do owner-occupied multi-unit buildings tend to be? The 1979 history places Shadyside's early apartment houses mainly between Walnut and Ellsworth and along Maryland Avenue, and it names Kentucky Avenue among the streets of modest houses on narrow lots. The 1890s triplex at 5810 Kentucky sits on one of those streets.
If you own one of Shadyside's divided Victorians, or want to buy one, Brian Teyssier can put a price on what the building is worth as a single-family home, as an owner-occupied rental and as condos, so you can compare all three before you decide. Request a free home valuation or schedule a consultation.